Yoffie and Ben-Ami bat about Israel issues at Town Hall
Monday, October 26, 2009 at 3:55PM Jeremy Ben-Ami and Rabbi Eric Yoffie held a “Jewish Community Town Hall” this afternoon moderated by Jane Eisner, editor of The Forward. Yoffie is the president of the Union for Reform Judaism. In December, Yoffie and J Street started a small war of words over the way Israel conducted Operation Cast Lead.
Yoffie is one of the few public critics of J Street to attend the conference. The Town Hall more closely resembled a formal debate: Yoffie spoke, Ben-Ami responded, and then both of them took questions from the audience.
Yoffie and Ben-Ami seemed to agree on more than they disagree, but they did disagree notably on a couple of points, particularly the Gaza War and the Goldstone Report. The nature of that disagreement, to my mind, is when and how to criticize Israel. Ben-Ami said to consider allegations; Yoffie said to consider context first.
J-Street